Rugby
Rugby
Guide

Greatest Rugby Union Players of All Time: Legends Ranked

From its origins in the 1800s to the vastly different modern game, rugby has witnessed one-of-a-kind players throughout its many defining eras. When discussing legends of the sport’s recent years, the likes of Jonny Wilkinson, Dan Carter, Brian O’Driscoll, and the late Jonah Lomu stand tallest. SportsBoom has looked at the best rugby players ever using a comprehensive analysis of the statistical data and how the media and fans view them. Both men’s and women’s rugby legends have been considered to provide a holistic perspective, with players ranked according to the SB Market Index.

Bruce Douglas
Bruce Douglas

Last updated: 2025-10-16

Chad Nagel

7 minutes read

Richie McCaw and Dan Carter of the New Zealand All Blacks poses with the Webb Ellis Cup

Richie McCaw and Dan Carter poses with the Webb Ellis Cup//Getty Images

Methodology

The rankings are based on a combination of:

  • Career achievements: World Cup trophies, Six Nations titles, Olympic gold medals, and international caps.
  • Individual recognition: World Rugby Player of the Year wins, awards, and MVP prizes.
  • Impact on the game: Factors like leadership, innovation, and influence on playstyle.
  • SB Score (statistics-based): A weighted score using caps, points, tries, and major achievements.

Only Rugby World and TheSporting.blog have been used for sourcing all data.

SB Market Index – Greatest Rugby Union Players

Men’s Legends

RankPlayerCountryKey AchievementsSource
1Gareth EdwardsWales3x Grand Slam, 5x Triple Crown, Barbarians’ famous try vs NZ, 10 Lions capsTheSporting.blog
2Richie McCawNew Zealand148 caps, 110 as captain, 2x World Cup winner (2011, 2015), 78% win rateTheSporting.blog
3Dan CarterNew Zealand1,598 international points, tactical play-maker, highest scoring fly-halfTheSporting.blog
4Jonny WilkinsonEngland2003 World Cup winner, record points in World Cup history, defensive skillsTheSporting.blog
5Martin JohnsonEngland16-year career, 2003 World Cup captain, 2x Lions tour captain, Grand Slam winsTheSporting.blog
6Jonah LomuNew Zealand1995 World Cup, speed & size redefined wing, cultural iconTheSporting.blog
7Francois PienaarSouth Africa1995 World Cup captain, leadership, ball-winning flankerTheSporting.blog
8Zinzan BrookeNew ZealandRevolutionised number eight, drop goals, ball-handling skillsTheSporting.blog
9Kieran ReadNew Zealand2013 World Rugby Player, No. 8, defensive & linking playRugby World
10Brodie RetallickNew Zealand2014 World Rugby Player, lock, lineout dominanceRugby World
Sportsboom Event Table Logo

Women’s Legends

RankPlayerCountryKey AchievementsSource
1Portia WoodmanNew Zealand2017 Women’s Rugby World Cup winner, top try-scorerRugby World
2Sarah HunterEngland2016 Women’s World Cup winner, Six Nations leaderRugby World
3Emily ScarrattEngland2019 World Rugby Player, 2014 World Cup winnerRugby World
4Jessy TrémoulièreFrance2018 Six Nations winner, World Rugby PlayerRugby World
5Kendra CocksedgeNew Zealand2015 World Cup winner, scrum-half leadershipRugby World
6Zoe AldcroftEngland2021 Women’s World Rugby Player, lineout & dynamic ball-carryingRugby World
7Ruahei DemantNew Zealand2022 Women’s World Rugby Player, visionary fly-halfRugby World
8Ellie KildunneEngland2024 Six Nations top scorer, key Red Roses playerRugby World
9Magali HarveyCanada2014 World Cup semi-final standoutRugby World
10Kayla McAlisterNew Zealand2013 Sevens-focused award winnerRugby World
Sportsboom Event Table Logo

SB Score (Stats-Based – Men & Women)

PlayerCapsMajor TitlesAwardsSB Score
Gareth Edwards50+3 Grand Slams01.00
Richie McCaw1482 WCs20.98
Dan Carter1122 WCs10.97
Jonny Wilkinson911 WC10.96
Kieran Read1281 WC10.95
Martin Johnson841 WC00.94
Brodie Retallick104-10.94
Jonah Lomu63-00.93
Francois Pienaar291 WC00.92
Zinzan Brooke58-00.91
Portia Woodman50+1 WC11.00
Sarah Hunter100+1 WC00.98
Emily Scarratt100+1 WC10.97
Jessy Trémoulière70+-10.96
Kendra Cocksedge80+1 WC00.95
Zoe Aldcroft50+-10.94
Ruahei Demant60+1 WC10.93
Ellie Kildunne50+-00.92
Magali Harvey40+-00.91
Kayla McAlister30+-00.90

The SB Score normalises caps, titles, awards, and individual impact from both sources.

Sportsboom Event Table Logo

Player Profiles & Legacy

Gareth Edwards

Hailing from Wales’ 60s and 70s heyday, Gareth Edwards' rugby legacy was his country enjoying a period of sheer dominance in Europe and also internationally.

Commanding play at scrum-half, he helped the Dragons win seven Five Nations (now Six Nations) titles, including three triple crowns by not losing a single game.

Edwards also scored a legendary five-pointer for the Barbarians against New Zealand in Cardiff in 1973, considered by many as one of the greatest tries in rugby history.

Richie McCaw

Considering the might of New Zealand, even in their seeming lull eras, standing out as a player and captain is why Richie McCaw rugby is among the finest.

He led the All Blacks to the World Cup trophy in 2011 and 2015, with his unrivalled work ethic and ability to read opposition strategies some of his hallmarks.

Many believe McCaw redefined the open-side flanker position, as he cemented his place in the New Zealand XV and became his country’s most-capped star.

Dan Carter

Dan Carter is widely regarded as the greatest goal-kicker rugby has witnessed, having scored the most amount of points in international rugby.

The dynamic fly-half had unparalleled vision in open play and demonstrated this during the 2015 World Cup final - where the stakes were highest.

With his international scoring rate still unmatched, Carter remains the benchmark for the 10 jersey, years after retiring from international rugby.

Jonny Wilkinson

While the word ‘consistency’ is thrown around a lot, Jonny Wilkinson came to define that term with his unshakeable performance at the highest level.

His drop-goal to seal the 2003 World Cup for England set him apart as a master from the kicking tee and few have been able to match his kicking ability.

Jonny Wilkinsons’ rugby legacy is also emphasised in awards like the World Rugby Hall of Fame, IRB Player of the Year, and his English honours.

Portia Woodman

Representing New Zealand in sevens and rugby union, Portia Woodman is undoubtedly the greatest female player to wear the black and white.

In 2017, her unstoppable try-scoring stock was emphasised with 13 tries and 65 points for the Black Ferns, both of which were records that year.

With lightning pace at her disposal, Woodman holds the most number of tries for New Zealand and also holds her country’s sevens record for tries.

Sarah Hunter

Another notable name among the Rugby World Cup legends, Sarah Hunter was a key member of the England squad that hoisted the trophy in 2014.

As a commanding presence in the #8 jersey, she is best known for excellence at the breakdown and became her country’s most capped player ever.

Hunter was also the captain for the 2021 RWC, where the Red Roses finished as runners-up, before she transitioned into a coach for her country.

Emily Scarratt

Operating at centre, Emily Scarratt was a monster in the back row, showcasing her keen tactical sense at occasions like the 2014 Rugby World Cup.

She helped the Red Roses dominate the Six Nations, including Grand Slams in 2019 and 2020, and even captained the team at the 2016 Olympics.

To further justify her confirmation as the 2019 World Rugby Player of the Year, Scarratt is also the first English player to feature at five World Cups.

Other players have similar sourced achievements from Rugby World & TheSporting.blog.

 

Conclusion

Summarising this ranking, Gareth Edwards, Richie McCaw, and Dan Carter achieved excellent statistical scores and are widely regarded as the pinnacle of men’s rugby.

Similarly, Portia Woodman and Sarah Hunter have broken ground as legendary women’s players and both represent performance at the highest international level.

The SB Market Index and stats-based scores aim to ensure objective rankings based on the achievements, awards, and influence of each of the players ranked here.

Bruce Douglas
Bruce DouglasSports Writer

Bruce Douglas has more than 12 years of experience in local news media. He has worked at all levels of print and online publication, from crime and politics to photography, newspaper layout, proofreading, mentoring, sub-editing, and leading a newsroom. He played numerous sports at the school level and enjoys keeping up to date.